Conjunction-Based Proximity Rules in Subject-Verb Agreement
Master the 'Rule of Proximity' for correlative conjunctions like Either-Or and Neither-Nor. Essential grammar for SSC, Banking, and competitive exams.
When Subjects Compete for Attention
In the previous lesson, we explored the nuanced differences between ‘Each’ and ‘Every’ and how they always force a singular verb, even when the group is large. But what happens when you have two different subjects tied together, and they aren’t the same? Imagine a sentence where one subject is singular (like “the teacher”) and the other is plural (like “the students”).
When these different subjects are joined by special “choice-making” words, a conflict arises. Which one should the verb follow? The answer lies in a simple physical rule: the subject that stands closest to the verb wins the right to decide.
In English grammar, this is known as the Rule of Proximity. “Proximity” simply means “closeness.” This rule is a major favorite for examiners in SSC CGL and IBPS exams because it tests your ability to ignore the first subject and focus only on the one that actually matters for the verb.
The Choice-Making Conjunctions
The Rule of Proximity does not apply to every sentence. It is strictly reserved for a specific set of conjunctions that offer a choice or an alternative between two subjects. These are often called “Correlative Conjunctions” because they work in pairs.
There are four primary structures where you must apply the Rule of Proximity:
Neither… nor (Negative choice)
Neither… nor (எதிர்மறைத் தேர்வு) Neither… nor (नकारात्मक विकल्प) Either… or (Positive choice)
Either… or (நேர்மறைத் தேர்வு) Either… or (सकारात्मक विकल्प) Not only… but also (Additional choice)
Not only… but also (கூடுதல் தேர்வு) Not only… but also (अतिरिक्त विकल्प) Or / Nor (Simple choice)
Or / Nor (எளியத் தேர்வு) Or / Nor (साधारण विकल्प)
Whenever you see these words connecting two subjects, you must mentally “block out” the first subject and look only at the second one to determine the verb.
Analogy · The Neighbor's Decision Expand analogy
Imagine you are standing at a window. Two people are walking toward you, but only the person standing right in front of the window can talk to you. No matter how loud or large the person further away is, you only listen to the one closest to the glass. In grammar, the verb only “listens” to the subject standing right next to it.
How the Rule Operates
To master this rule, you must train your eyes to skip the first noun after “Neither,” “Either,” or “Not only.” Instead, jump straight to the noun after “nor,” “or,” or “but also.”
1. Singular Subject + Plural Subject
If the subject closer to the verb is plural, the verb must be plural.
Example: Neither the manager nor the employees are happy with the new policy.
உதாரணம்: Neither the manager nor the employees are happy with the new policy. (மேலாளரோ அல்லது ஊழியர்களோ புதிய கொள்கையில் மகிழ்ச்சியாக இல்லை.) उदाहरण: Neither the manager nor the employees are happy with the new policy. Analysis: The “manager” is singular, but we ignore him. The “employees” are plural and closest to the verb “are.” Therefore, we use the plural verb.
விளக்கம்: “manager” ஒருமையாக இருந்தாலும், நாம் அவரைப் பொருட்படுத்தவில்லை. “employees” பன்மையாக இருப்பதோடு, “are” என்ற வினைச்சொல்லுக்கு மிக அருகிலும் உள்ளனர். எனவே, நாம் பன்மை வினைச்சொல்லைப் பயன்படுத்துகிறோம். विश्लेषण: यहाँ “manager” एकवचन है, लेकिन हम उस पर ध्यान नहीं देते। “employees” बहुवचन हैं और क्रिया “are” के सबसे करीब हैं। इसलिए, हम बहुवचन क्रिया का उपयोग करते हैं।
2. Plural Subject + Singular Subject
If you swap the positions, the verb changes entirely.
Example: Neither the employees nor the manager is happy with the new policy.
உதாரணம்: Neither the employees nor the manager is happy with the new policy. उदाहरण: Neither the employees nor the manager is happy with the new policy. Analysis: Now, “manager” is the subject closest to the verb. Since “manager” is singular, the verb must be “is.”
விளக்கம்: இப்போது, “manager” வினைச்சொல்லுக்கு மிக அருகில் இருக்கும் Subject ஆக மாறுகிறார். “manager” ஒருமையாக இருப்பதினால், வினைச்சொல் “is” என்று இருக்க வேண்டும். विश्लेषण: अब, “manager” क्रिया के सबसे नजदीक वाला कर्ता है। चूँकि “manager” एकवचन है, इसलिए क्रिया “is” होनी चाहिए।
3. The “Not Only… But Also” Pattern
This is where many aspirants make mistakes because they feel the sentence is adding things together (like the word “and”).
Incorrect: Not only the students but also the teacher are coming.
தவறானது: Not only the students but also the teacher are coming. गलत: Not only the students but also the teacher are coming. Correct: Not only the students but also the teacher is coming.
சரியானது: Not only the students but also the teacher is coming. सही: Not only the students but also the teacher is coming. Analysis: Even though both students and the teacher are coming, the rule of proximity dictates that the verb must agree with “teacher,” which is singular.
விளக்கம்: மாணவர்கள் மற்றும் ஆசிரியர் இருவருமே வந்தாலும், Rule of Proximity விதியின்படி வினைச்சொல் “teacher” என்பதோடு உடன்பட வேண்டும், இது ஒருமையாகும். विश्लेषण: भले ही विद्यार्थी और शिक्षक दोनों आ रहे हैं, लेकिन समीपता का नियम यह कहता है कि क्रिया “teacher” के अनुसार होनी चाहिए, जो कि एकवचन है।
Nuances of the Nearest Subject
While the basic rule is simple, examiners often use specific words to see if you can still identify the correct verb form.
Collective Nouns as Nearest Subjects
If the subject closest to the verb is a collective noun like staff, committee, or team, you should treat it as singular unless the sentence implies the members are acting individually. In most exam questions, these are treated as singular.
- Example: Not only the students but also the library staff is participating.
உதாரணம்: Not only the students but also the library staff is participating. उदाहरण: Not only the students but also the library staff is participating.
Two Plural Subjects
If both subjects are plural, the “closeness” rule still works, but it results in a plural verb because the nearest subject is plural.
- Example: Neither the actors nor the directors are ready.
உதாரணம்: Neither the actors nor the directors are ready. उदाहरण: Neither the actors nor the directors are ready.
Different Verb Forms
The proximity rule applies to all auxiliary verbs (is/are, was/were, has/have).
Example: Either the principal or the teachers have the key. (Plural have)
உதாரணம்: Either the principal or the teachers have the key. (பன்மை have) उदाहरण: Either the principal or the teachers have the key. (बहुवचन have) Example: Either the teachers or the principal has the key. (Singular has)
உதாரணம்: Either the teachers or the principal has the key. (ஒருமை has) उदाहरण: Either the teachers or the principal has the key. (एकवचन has)
Special Case: Agreement with Pronouns
The Rule of Proximity becomes even more critical when the subjects are pronouns like I, You, He, or She. Because these pronouns require different forms of the verb “to be” (am, is, are), you must be very careful.
| Sentence Structure | Correct Verb | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Either he or I | am | Verb agrees with “I” |
| Either I or he | is | Verb agrees with “he” |
| Either he or you | are | Verb agrees with “you” |
In your exam, if you see a sentence like “Neither he nor I is going,” mark it as an error immediately. The correct form is “Neither he nor I am going.”
The Professional Convention
While it is grammatically correct to put the singular subject near the verb when the other is plural, professional writers usually follow a helpful convention. To make sentences sound “heavier” and more natural, they usually place the plural subject closest to the verb.
Better: Either the principal or the teachers have the keys.
சிறந்தது: Either the principal or the teachers have the keys. बेहतर: Either the principal or the teachers have the keys. Less Natural: Either the teachers or the principal has the keys.
இயல்பு குறைந்தது: Either the teachers or the principal has the keys. कम स्वाभाविक: Either the teachers or the principal has the keys.
Both are technically correct, but the first one is the standard pattern you will see in most reading comprehension passages in bank exams.
Contrast: Proximity vs. Addition
It is easy to confuse the Rule of Proximity with the basic rule of the word And.
The “And” Rule: When you use “and,” you are forming a team. 1 + 1 = 2 (Plural).
“And” விதி: நீங்கள் “and” ஐப் பயன்படுத்தும்போது, ஒரு குழுவை உருவாக்குகிறீர்கள். 1 + 1 = 2 (பன்மை). “And” नियम: जब आप “and” का उपयोग करते हैं, तो आप एक समूह (team) बना रहे होते हैं। 1 + 1 = 2 (बहुवचन)। - Example: The teacher and the student are here.
உதாரணம்: The teacher and the student are here. उदाहरण: The teacher and the student are here.
- Example: The teacher and the student are here.
The Proximity Rule: When you use choice-words, you are not adding. You are selecting the nearest one.
Proximity விதி: நீங்கள் தேர்வுச் சொற்களைப் பயன்படுத்தும்போது, நீங்கள் கூட்டுவதில்லை. வினைச்சொல்லுக்கு மிக அருகிலுள்ள ஒன்றைத் தேர்ந்தெடுக்கிறீர்கள். समीपता नियम: जब आप विकल्प वाले शब्दों का उपयोग करते हैं, तब आप जोड़ नहीं रहे होते हैं। आप सबसे नज़दीकी वाले को चुन रहे होते हैं। - Example: Either the teacher or the student is here.
உதாரணம்: Either the teacher or the student is here. उदाहरण: Either the teacher or the student is here.
- Example: Either the teacher or the student is here.
Remember, choice-words create a “boundary” that stops you from counting the first subject.
Key Takeaways
The Rule of Proximity states that when subjects are joined by specific conjunctions, the verb agrees with the nearest subject.
Rule of Proximity விதியின்படி, குறிப்பிட்ட Conjunction-களால் Subject-கள் இணைக்கப்படும்போது, வினைச்சொல் மிக அருகிலுள்ள Subject-உடன் உடன்படும். Rule of Proximity यह बताता है कि जब कर्ता कुछ विशिष्ट संयोजकों (conjunctions) द्वारा जुड़े होते हैं, तो क्रिया निकटतम कर्ता के साथ सहमत होती है। This rule applies only to Either…or, Neither…nor, Not only…but also, and Or/Nor.
இந்த விதி Either…or, Neither…nor, Not only…but also, மற்றும் Or/Nor ஆகியவற்றுக்கு மட்டுமே பொருந்தும். यह नियम केवल Either…or, Neither…nor, Not only…but also, और Or/Nor पर ही लागू होता है। Always ignore the first subject mentioned in these constructions when deciding the verb.
வினைச்சொல்லைத் தீர்மானிக்கும்போது, இந்த அமைப்புகளில் குறிப்பிடப்பட்டுள்ள முதல் Subject-ஐ எப்போதும் புறக்கணித்துவிடுங்கள். क्रिया का निर्णय लेते समय इन संरचनाओं में उल्लिखित पहले कर्ता को हमेशा नजरअंदाज करें। If one of the subjects is a pronoun like I, the verb must be am if “I” is the nearest subject.
Subject-களில் ஒன்று I போன்ற Pronoun ஆக இருந்து, அது வினைச்சொல்லுக்கு அருகில் இருந்தால், வினைச்சொல் am என்று இருக்க வேண்டும். यदि कर्ताओं में से एक I जैसा सर्वनाम है, तो यदि “I” निकटतम कर्ता है तो क्रिया am होनी चाहिए। Do not treat these sentences like “And” sentences; they involve a choice, not a sum.
இந்த வாக்கியங்களை “And” வாக்கியங்களைப் போலக் கருத வேண்டாம்; இவை ஒரு தேர்வைக் குறிக்கின்றன, தொகையைக் (கூடுதல்) குறிக்கவில்லை. इन वाक्यों को “And” वाले वाक्यों की तरह न मानें; इनमें एक विकल्प शामिल होता है, योग (sum) नहीं। In the next lesson, we will look at Accompaniment Modifiers like “Along with” and “As well as,” where we cover crucial exam-tested scenarios including collective nouns, indefinite pronouns, and the ‘Chief Guest’ rule for identifying the primary subject.
அடுத்த பாடத்தில், “Along with” மற்றும் “As well as” போன்ற Accompaniment Modifiers பற்றிப் பார்ப்போம். இதில் கூட்டுப் பெயர்ச்சொற்கள் (Collective Nouns), காலவரையற்ற பிரதிப்பெயர்ச்சொற்கள் (Indefinite Pronouns) மற்றும் முதன்மை எழுவாயைக் கண்டறிவதற்கான ‘Chief Guest’ விதி போன்ற தேர்வுக்குத் தேவையான முக்கியமான நுணுக்கங்களை விரிவாகக் காண்போம். अगले पाठ में, हम “Along with” और “As well as” जैसे Accompaniment Modifiers को देखेंगे। इसमें हम सामूहिक संज्ञा (Collective Nouns), अनिश्चितकालीन सर्वनाम (Indefinite Pronouns) और प्राथमिक कर्ता (Primary Subject) को पहचानने के ‘Chief Guest’ नियम जैसे महत्वपूर्ण परीक्षा-उपयोगी सूक्ष्म नियमों को विस्तार से पढ़ेंगे।
Check Your Understanding
Test your knowledge with these practice questions
Conjunction-Based Proximity Rules - Practice Quiz
Master the Rule of Proximity with this practice quiz. Test your ability to correctly align verbs with subjects when using Either-Or, Neither-Nor, and Not Only-But Also.
Reviews & Ratings
What readers think about this lesson
About Scoreclever
Your Complete Learning Ecosystem
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning technique that make memorization and revision effortless.
Explore Scoreclever